Plus 39 Italian Restaurant & Lounge
The Hotel Peace & Plenty has a long history dating back to the 1700’s. It changed hands in 2017, and the new owners wanted to preserve the rich heritage of the building.
The hotel’s restaurant reopened in December 2017, with an amazing Italian Restaurant, whose proprietors are from Milan.
"Plus 39 Italian Restaurant and Lounge", offers local cuisine including grits with breakfast and conch burgers for lunch. Their dinner menu ranges from Italian fare, to steak, and seafood, including grouper. There are also some wonderful Italian dishes, like spaghetti bolognese, prepared by Chef Mattia, with many of the ingredients being imported from Italy.
There are lots of specialty nights, such as Asian Night, Indian Night, Taco Tuesdays, and Jazz & Meatball Night.
There is also Pasta Buffet Night, and an Italian Buffet Night, that will make you want to eat there every night, so as not to miss any of these great dishes.
Every Thursday night is BBQ night with a Rake and Scrape band, a local favorite surely not to be missed.
The Restaurant offers two bars. The 'Pool Deck’ bar, is a fun place to have afternoon or evening drinks and look at the beautiful azure water.
There is also an inside bar. This 200 year old room, that was originally a “ Slave Kitchen”, has lots of history, and is still tended by Lerman “ Doc” Rolle on Tuesday nights. Doc has been a bartender at the Peace and Plenty Hotel for 50 years.
Be sure to make Plus 39 Restaurant & Lounge one of the first stops on your list of restaurants to go to in Exuma, as you will want to go there again and again!